unsolved.now

the board / Chemistry

Life's Homochirality

Life is built almost entirely from left-handed molecules, and nobody knows why

open for 178 years

posed 1848 · Louis Pasteur, who discovered molecular chirality by separating mirror-image crystals

The amino acids in every living thing are almost all 'left-handed' and its sugars 'right-handed', though chemistry makes both mirror images equally — so how did life come to use only one hand?

The problem

Many molecules come in two forms that are mirror images of each other, like a left and right hand — and ordinary chemical reactions produce both in equal amounts. Yet life is startlingly one-handed: it builds proteins almost exclusively from left-handed amino acids and uses right-handed sugars, a property called homochirality that is essential for biology to work. How the early Earth broke the symmetry and locked in a single handedness — whether by chance, mineral surfaces, circularly polarized starlight, or some amplifying chemistry — remains unresolved. Pasteur discovered chirality in 1848, and the origin of life's specific choice has been debated ever since.

Why it matters

Homochirality is a prerequisite for the origin of life, so explaining it is part of explaining how life began. It also matters intensely to medicine: the two hands of a drug molecule can have completely different effects in the body, and understanding chiral selection guides how we make them.

Progress so far

  • 1848Louis Pasteur separates mirror-image tartaric acid crystals, discovering molecular chirality
  • 1953the Miller–Urey experiment produces amino acids, but as equal mixtures of both hands
  • 1995–2001the Soai reaction demonstrates chemical autocatalysis that amplifies a tiny chiral imbalance into near-total one-handedness
  • 2020sanalyses of meteorite amino acids and circularly polarized light keep the origin of the initial bias an open question

References

  1. Wikipedia — the puzzle, proposed mechanisms, and why it remains unresolved
  2. Wikipedia — Pasteur's 1848 discovery and the chemistry of mirror-image molecules
Status: open. Verified still unsolved as of 2026-07-24. Every date, name, and claim above traces to the references; if this problem falls, the board will say so.